This month, we’re bringing the energy of the city that never sleeps straight to your pup’s toy basket. From Lady Liberty to street-corner pizza slices, this box is all about big-city play with serious enrichment value—no MetroCard required. We tested the Liberty Nose Work toy with Miley and Charlie—Miley treated it like a treasure hunt, methodically working treats out of the hidden pocket, while Charlie paraded it around the house like he’d just conquered the five boroughs.
This Month’s Treats
RYŌKEN INSTINCT Seafood Treat & Snack Bar by Ryōken Instinct
Think of this as a protein bar for your dog—because that’s exactly what it is. Made with wild-caught salmon, codfish, green-lipped mussels, and blueberries, this pre-scored bar is designed to fuel metabolism, support joint recovery, and sustain energy on long walks or training days. The texture is dense but breaks cleanly, making it perfect for tucking into pockets or enrichment toys. Use it post-adventure or as high-value training fuel.
Ingredients: Wild-caught salmon, codfish, green-lipped mussels, blueberries
Why We Love This Brand: Founded by Martha, a Stanford PhD in biochemistry, and her partner Michael, Ryōken Instinct was born on the trail when they couldn’t find treats that met the metabolic needs of their dogs, Miru and Miji. Handmade in Seattle with regeneratively sourced ingredients from Pacific Northwest family farms, every bar is formulated to reduce inflammation and support long-term vitality.
Sourdog Sweet Potato Sourdough Dog Treats by Sourdog
Gut-friendly, crunchy, and made with fermented sourdough starter, these treats are for the dog (and human) who reads ingredient labels. Sweet potato and peanut butter balance out the tang of the sourdough, while rye flour and flaxseed add fiber and omega-3s. The fermentation process makes them easier to digest—ideal for sensitive stomachs or picky eaters. Use them as training rewards, food toppers, or enrichment stuffing.
Ingredients: Rye flour, sweet potato, peanut butter (peanuts), sourdough starter (fermented rye flour & water), flaxseed, salt
Why We Love This Brand: Small-batch and made in Southern California, Sourdog is free from common meat allergens, chemicals, and preservatives. Their sourdough fermentation process supports gut health naturally—no shortcuts, just clean ingredients and time.
Enrichment Toy of the Month
Come Here Buddy Liberty Nose Work Dog Toy
Lady Liberty gets a job upgrade this month: treat dispenser. This 12-inch plush features a hidden pocket at the base where you can tuck kibble or small treats, turning snack time into a focused foraging session. The squeaker keeps things playful, but the real magic is in the mental workout—your dog has to problem-solve to access the reward. Charlie claimed this one immediately and carried it around like a trophy; Miley worked it slowly and deliberately, nose-first.
Why We Love This Brand: Come Here Buddy creates landmark-themed enrichment toys that turn geography into play. Their designs encourage natural sniffing instincts and problem-solving, making them ideal for dogs who need more than just a squeaker to stay engaged.
Toys and Treats Box for Large Dogs
Hugsmart Pet Jumbo Foodie Pizza by Hugsmart Pet
New York-style pizza, minus the grease. This jumbo plush features embroidered toppings, a built-in squeaker, and a treat pocket on top for hide-and-seek fun. It’s soft enough for comfort play but sturdy enough for fetch and light tug sessions. The treat pocket adds an enrichment layer—stuff it, let them discover it, repeat.
Why We Love This Brand: With over 35 years in the toy industry starting as a family-run children’s toy business in 1985, Hugsmart Pet brings the same high safety standards to pet products. Their mission is simple: make innovative, fashion-forward toys that meet modern pet parents’ lifestyles with quality you can trust.
Extra Toy: CHEWFFON Bagel Plush Squeaky Dog Toy by CHEWFFO
A New York bagel with all the fixings: two squeakers, crinkle paper hidden in the cream cheese layer, and pockets between the “bread” for treat-hiding. This toy works double duty as a comfort plush and a beginner-level snuffle game. Hide treats in the layers and watch your dog use their nose to fish them out—it’s foraging practice disguised as breakfast.
Why We Love This Brand: CHEWFFON designs nosework toys inspired by everyday joy. Their snuffle toys are leveled (this one’s Level 1), so you can match the challenge to your dog’s experience. Every toy is built to stimulate natural sniffing instincts while reducing boredom and anxiety.
Toys and Treats Box for Medium Dogs
PLAY Totally Touristy Statue of Liberty Dog Toy – Medium by P.L.A.Y.
A tourist-ready Lady Liberty that squeaks and crinkles, complete with a tablet reading “In Treats We Trust.” Hand-crafted with double-layer exterior and reinforced stitching, this isn’t a one-session toy—it’s built to last through fetch, tug, and enthusiastic play. The eco-friendly PlanetFill is made from 100% post-consumer recycled plastic bottles, and the whole thing is machine washable.
Why We Love This Brand: P.L.A.Y. (Pet Lifestyle and You) creates stylish, eco-conscious pet products without compromising on quality. Every toy features AZO-free dyes and meets the same strict safety standards as infant and children’s products. Luxury meets sustainability—and it’s made to last.
Hugsmart Pet Food Party Pizza by Hugsmart Pet
Same pizza love, medium-sized. Squeaker for play, treat pocket for focus. Whether your dog likes to shake, fetch, or cuddle their toys, this one adapts. The embroidered details and plush texture make it a favorite for dogs who rotate their toy collection nightly.
Extra Toy: fabdog NYC Taxi by fabdog
Every New Yorker has a taxi story—now your dog has one too. This plush yellow cab features one squeaker and looks like the real deal, right down to the details. Compact enough for indoor fetch, soft enough for couch time, and durable enough for daily play. It’s the kind of toy that ends up in the “bring everywhere” rotation.
Why We Love This Brand: fabdog has been a trusted name in the pet industry for over 20 years, featured in People Magazine and Vogue. As members of the Pet Sustainability Coalition, they’re committed to clever design, stellar construction, and making the environment better for pets and people alike.
Toys and Treats Box for Small Dogs
PLAY Totally Touristy Statue of Liberty Dog Toy – Small by P.L.A.Y.
All the same features as the medium version—squeaker, crinkle, “In Treats We Trust” tablet, reinforced stitching, eco-friendly fill, machine washable—sized perfectly for smaller jaws. Great for fetch, tug, or just proudly displaying around the house.
In Pizza We Crust Latex Dog Toys Set of 2 by Petshop by Fringe Studio
Two latex squeaker toys—one pizza slice, one beer—because pizza in New York comes with a side. Made with natural latex and super loud squeakers, this set is designed for interactive play. Lightweight and easy to carry, perfect for fetch or solo play sessions. The latex material has some give, making it gentler on teeth than hard rubber. Not for aggressive chewers, but ideal for dogs who love variety and volume.
Extra Toy: Hugsmart Pet Food Party Hot Dog by Hugsmart Pet
A New York street-cart classic. This plush hot dog features two rope knots on each side—perfect for chewing like a true connoisseur—plus a squeaker inside to add extra spice to playtime. Perfectly sized for small-dog mouths, whether they’re shaking it, carrying it, or using it as a pillow.
Why This Box Matters
New York City isn’t just a place—it’s a mindset. Curious, relentless, always moving. This box channels that energy into enrichment that works: nose work that builds confidence, plush that invites connection, and treats that fuel real metabolic needs. Every item earned its spot.
Share your NYC adventures with us on Instagram @pupper.crust
Important Safety Reminder
Every dog is different. Supervise your pup while playing with new toys, especially those with detachable parts or hidden surprises. Remove any damaged toys to prevent accidental ingestion. Product selection may vary based on your dog’s size, preferences, and allergies listed during sign-up as well as product availability.
